Life cycle of plants lesson

Click Here to Download this Answer Instantly

Case Analysis Rubric Case Analysis Rubric

Criteria Ratings Pts

This criterion is linked to a Learning Outcome Problem Statement Definition: How precisely have you identified the problem? Did you identify the true problem and not just symptoms of the problem?

The problem is to determine the market value of each soccer player. This market value is essential for success of a team in league. It will help clubs to spend their money in most effective way. The determination of variable on which the market value of each player depends, is the main problem.

10.0 pts Full Marks 0.0 pts No Marks 10.0 pts

This criterion is linked to a Learning Outcome Situation Analysis: Did you summarize the key factors most relevant to the case?

The purchasing and selling of player by club depends on the market value of each player. The market value depends on both qualitative and quantitative aspects of each player. As there are many variables which may affect the market value of each player, therefore sometime the market value is arbitrary. Due to which there are possible markups and markdowns in market value in new setting.

10.0 pts Full Marks 0.0 pts No Marks 10.0 pts

This criterion is linked to a Learning Outcome Alternative Identification: How plausible are the alternatives you identify? How thoughtfully are they developed? Do you address pros and cons?

Two alternatives have been used, one is the correlation and other is the regression analysis. The correlation suggests that there is no strong correlation of each variable to market value on individual basis and even some of them do have negative correlation. But when using the regression analysis the quantitative variable gives the correct answer. However, the qualitative variables such as position, foot, NR and CR have not been included in the analysis.

10.0 pts Full Marks 0.0 pts No Marks 10.0 pts

This criterion is linked to a Learning Outcome Recommendation: How convincing is your recommended course of action? Is it justified and supported by evidence? Did you critically evaluate the recommendation in terms of pros and cons? Does the recommendation make sense given your analysis?

It is recommended to use regression analysis technique to determine the market value of each player, it is evident from the fact that the average market value is 34.20 and the regression equation gives the value of 34.64, which is near to the average market value.

20.0 pts Full Marks 0.0 pts No Marks 20.0 pts

This criterion is linked to a Learning Outcome Quality of Data Analysis: Did you incorporate data from the case into a meaningful analysis? Do you use the numbers to evaluate alternatives and justify a recommendation? Are your calculations accurate, appropriate, and directly relate to the problem you identified?

The data from the case has been used properly to use the two techniques which evident from the fact that they give accurate answer as the average value are equal to value determined by regression analysis. The qualitative variables have not been used correctly as they will have no major impact on the market value of each player; once again it is evident from the fact that exclusion of those variables produces the correct result.

50.0 pts Full Marks 0.0 pts No Marks 50.0 pts

This criterion is linked to a Learning Outcome Writing Quality: Was the paper easy to read – well-organized, grammatically correct, correct spelling etc.? (Overall grade may be adjusted accordingly)

Yes it was easy to read and understand the case study and it did not create much problem in understanding the fact and the use of data given in excel sheet.